Material identification codes in packaging recycling labels: how exactly to fill in 20 / 21 / 22 / 23—the three types of boundary errors most commonly printed wrong
💡 💡 At a Glance
The two digits to the right of the triangular arrow are not filled in arbitrarily: 20 = paper and cardboard, 21 = non-recyclable composite materials, 22 = composite material classification, 23 = other materials. The three most common printing errors are: labeling composite paper bags as 20, using the recycling symbol and the word “recyclable” interchangeably, and omitting the material classification explanatory text. Before accepting such orders, printing companies must clarify the material composition and whether the materials have actually entered the recycling system.
A client who makes tea bags sent over the design draft. The recycling mark was drawn very much to standard: a triangle of arrows, with “PAP 21” underneath.
I asked him: What is the inner layer of this bag made of? He said: It is a composite; the inner layer is aluminum foil.
I said then it cannot be marked 21. The client was surprised: But we copied the template exactly for our recycling mark. He was right—the template was not the problem. The mistake was thatthe numbers on the template were not intended for bags like his..
As for recycling marks on packaging, more and more clients have been asking about this since 2026, but both the quality of their questions and the mistakes they make are about the same. Two-thirds of people assume that “recycling mark = this item is recyclable.” The remaining third know there are numbers, but they just copy them from whatever template they have. This article will explain what the two digits to the right of the triangular arrows mean, and then cover two less obvious mistakes.
First, let’s clarify: what these two numbers mean
The triangle of arrows is the graphic part, and the two digits in the lower-right corner areMaterial identification code, originating from the internationally recognized packaging recycling labeling system ISO 14021. The corresponding Chinese national standard is GB/T 18455. Numbers and materials have fixed correspondences and are not custom-assigned:
20indicates paper and cardboard;21indicates a non-recyclable composite material;22indicates a composite material, requiring additional material-category explanatory text below;23It indicates other material categories, and a description must also be added.
The tea bag mentioned earlier has an aluminum foil inner layer, making it a composite material. It must therefore either bear code 22 with “paper/aluminum” specified, or be marked with code 21 as a non-recyclable composite material—depending on whether it actually enters the recyclable paper collection stream. The core determination logic is:Whether the entire package can be thrown into the paper recycling bin without being torn open or contaminated.
If it can be thrown in whole and is made of cardboard, mark it with code 20. If it must be torn open, is contaminated with oil or grease, or is a composite material that no one accepts in the recycling system, mark it with code 21 or 22 and clearly state its materials. That concludes this point, so the client no longer has to agonize over the tea bag—the inner layer of his bag is aluminum foil, so it was ultimately marked with code 22 and “PAP/ALU.”
The first common mistake: describing a composite structure under code 22 as code 21
The difference between codes 21 and 22 is one of the most easily confused distinctions in the labeling industry because they look almost identical.
21 means “non-recyclable composite material.”This is a one-line categorization; there is no need to describe the material composition again.22 means “composite material suitable for separate recycling.”Supplementary text must be added below the label, specifying which materials are combined, such as “PAP/PE” or “PAP/ALU.”
A real-world failure looked like this: a customer making coffee bags used a structure of kraft paper + aluminum foil + PE laminate. After perforating the inner PE layer, it could actually be torn off and recycled separately. The design draft labeled it 21 because “PE is difficult to recycle.”
However, when the printing factory produced a sample, it found that the proposal required an easy-tear opening at the top of the bag, indicating that the customer had intended to make the PE layer tear off separately—so the bag wasa composite material suitable for separate recycling.It should have been labeled 22 with “PAP/ALU/PE” written beneath it. Labeling it 21 would effectively tell recyclers, “Do not accept this item as a whole,” directly contradicting the customer’s own easy-tear design.
The same issue is common on the other side as well: a composite material that is clearly inseparable is labeled “22,” but no explanatory text is provided. The line beneath “22” is mandatory, not decorative. A “22” without an explanation is treated the same as an incorrect label during packaging compliance checks.
The second type of error: recycling symbol ≠ recyclability
This type of error does not show up in the numbers, but in the nature of the entire matter.
Printing a recycling symbol merely states, “This package is made of XX material and should be placed in the XX recycling stream.” By itself, it does not constitute any promise of recyclability.What truly determines whether it can be recycled is whether a corresponding recycling stream is available locally, whether recyclers will accept it, and whether the composite materials can be separated.
This is where packaging brand owners are most likely to run into trouble. European clients who export products will print a green-dot symbol (the Triman logo) and an explanatory statement on the package, specifying which collection system it should be placed in. The French system is a typical example,and even matters such as a blanket ban on the green dot vary in interpretation from country to country.If the same batch of goods is also sold in the Japanese market, the labeling requirements are different again.
So, when the printing factory receives an order with recycling marks, there is one question it must ask:“Which market is this mark intended for? Has the customer provided the label template and explanatory copy for that market?”If the customer does not provide a template and the printing factory designs it on its own, that is the most typical point of failure for this kind of order.
The third type of mistake: attaching a paper self-adhesive label to a composite bag, blocking the recycling stream.
Strictly speaking, this type is not that the mark itself is wrong, but that the mark and the actual product contradict each other.
The paper box itself is marked with the recycling symbol 20, indicating that it can go into waste paper recycling, but the box has a self-adhesive label with a PVC backing film. During sorting, this label cannot be peeled off, so the entire box is classified as contaminated waste paper.No matter how correctly the recycling symbol 20 is printed elsewhere, it cannot compensate for this label..
This type of problem is particularly common in packaging export orders because customers choose PVC for the label’s weather resistance and tear resistance, while PVC is explicitly considered a contaminant in paper recycling streams. Some brands in China have begun requiring packaging suppliers to provide a “recycle-ready” commitment, which consists of three points: the adhesive must be separable, the ink must not interfere with recycling, and label attachments must not compromise the overall recyclability of the package.
What the printer can do is compile a list of “all non-body materials used on this box” when receiving a structural order: the label’s substrate, the type of adhesive, and the materials used for ribbons, magnets, and stickers. If even one item on the list is a magnet or a PVC window, the paper box can no longer be considered recyclable.
Clarify everything in three questions before printing begins.
Here is a summary of what printers should do when accepting this type of order:
First question:“Please provide a layer-by-layer breakdown of the packaging materials, and I will identify the recycling code for each layer.”When customers say that something is “just paper,” they are often being imprecise. The material composition of laminated pouches, film-coated pouches, and gift boxes with liners can vary across five different types.
Second question:Which market is this recycling mark intended for? Are there official templates and explanatory text?For products sold across multiple markets, it is especially important to ask, because the labeling logic differs in the European Union, Japan, and the United States.
The third sentence:What are all the accessories on this packaging—labels, ribbons, magnets, and stickers—made of, respectively?Once this sentence is asked, it usually becomes clear whether the customer’s recycling claims are valid.
After asking these three questions, the printer can decide whether they dare to print this 20.A recycling mark is a claim, and a claim needs to be supported. The supporting evidence comes from the customer’s materials list and the target market, not from an image downloaded from the internet..
Further reading
The upstream and downstream of labeling and recycling can be viewed together through these articles:
- Three common printing errors in the triangular packaging recycling symbol under GB 18455—The graphic itself should be considered together with the number.
- Gaps in enforcing the three categories of packaging recycling label standards—Three questions printers’ triangular recycling arrows may be asked during a customer factory audit.
- The recyclability of paper packaging is undermined by three types of accessories—Magnets, metal fasteners, and PVC windows; adding a handle turns the entire box into mixed materials.
- The three real use cases of Triman and Info-tri in France—Printing green dots, size categories, and multi-person garment designs in the European market.
FAQ
What do 20, 21, 22, and 23 represent in packaging recycling labels?
This is the material identification code in the ISO 14021 / GB/T 18455 system: 20 indicates paper and cardboard, 21 indicates non-recyclable composite materials, 22 indicates composite materials that can be sorted for recycling (material classification descriptive text must be added below), and 23 indicates other materials. Numbers correspond to specific materials and cannot be customized or replaced at will.
Should composite paper bags be labeled 21 or 22?
See whether it can be separated. Mark as 21 those that cannot be separated and for which no one in the recycling system will accept them; mark as 22 those designed with tear-off openings so they can be disassembled and recycled separately, and indicate the material composition below, such as PAP/ALU. The practical criterion is whether the entire package can be thrown into the waste paper recycling stream without requiring manual separation.
Does printing a recycling symbol on the packaging mean that the package is guaranteed to be recyclable?
Does not equal. The recycling mark is a declaration of material composition, indicating what materials the product is made of and which recycling stream it should be sent to; it does not, by itself, constitute a recyclability guarantee. Whether a product is recyclable depends on whether a corresponding recycling stream exists locally, whether the recycler accepts it, and whether composite materials can be separated. Brands must also label the designated recycling system for the destination country in accordance with that country's requirements when exporting.
If you marked 22 but did not provide a material description below it, will it be judged unqualified?
Will be judged as non-compliant. The explanatory text for item 22 is mandatory content, not optional decoration. Item 22 without explanatory text and an incorrectly entered code are usually treated as the same type of issue in compliance checks; both are labeling or identification errors.
Will adhesive labels with a PVC backing film applied to cartons affect the recyclability markings on the cartons?
Yes. If the label cannot be removed during sorting, the carton will be classified as contaminated waste paper, making the “20” printed on the box effectively meaningless. When making a Recycle-Ready commitment, the label substrate, adhesive type, ribbon magnets, and all other non-body attachments must be evaluated separately. This is precisely why many paper packages are not actually recyclable.
If the same package will be sold in multiple countries, do the recycling marks need to be printed separately?
Yes. Different markets have different requirements for recycling symbols, material codes, explanatory text, and designated recycling systems. For example, some European countries restrict the use of the Green Dot symbol, while Japan has separate labeling rules for paper and plastics. Printing plants should require customers to provide official templates and copy for each market and should not apply versions intended for other markets on their own.
📚 📚 Related Recommendations
Need a Custom Packaging Solution?
Learn more about packaging, or consult directly for a custom solution and quote
