Packaging Printing Carbon Labels: 3 Real Implementation Forms — Product / Enterprise / Process Level — Which One Should Small & Mid-Sized Printers Do First?
💡 💡 At a Glance
3 forms of packaging printing carbon labels: ① Product-level (CO₂e value printed on each package, first year 150,000–300,000 RMB), ② Enterprise-level (annual carbon emission disclosure report, first year 80,000–150,000 RMB), ③ Process-level (single process carbon emission database, first year 20,000–50,000 RMB). Implementation path for small & mid-sized printers: Step 1 process-level → Step 2 enterprise-level → Step 3 product-level. When the customer asks about "carbon labels," the printer must ask 3 questions: brand / order amount / delivery cycle.
At the end of 2024, a printer in Zhejiang making export packaging — annual revenue of 35 million RMB, main customers being L'Oréal and Estée Lauder subsidiary claims. The printer had only previously done "enterprise-level carbon emission reports" (ISO 14064), and had not done "product-level carbon footprint" (ISO 14067). After taking the order, the printer realized that product-level carbon footprint requires 3 things: ① full product life cycle assessment (from raw material procurement to finished product delivery), ② carbon emission data collection for each process, ③ third-party verification & certification. Going through the whole process, the printer spent 220,000 RMB to obtain the first product carbon label — but the customer's order only covered 80% of the cost, so the printer lost 44,000 RMB.
The root cause of this case is not "the printer should not have done it," but rather "the printer did not distinguish the differences among the 3 forms of carbon labels." The compliance requirements, costs, and applications of the 3 forms are completely different — product-level suits export high-end brands, enterprise-level suits listed companies and major customer supply chain requirements, process-level suits internal carbon management at the printer. The most common selection mistake for small & mid-sized printers is "start with product-level," but in reality they should first do "enterprise-level" or "process-level" to build a foundation.
Type 1: Product-Level Carbon Label — The "CO₂e Value" Printed on Each Package
Product-level carbon label is the carbon footprint value printed on each package, such as "CO₂e 120g / 100g packaging" or "carbon footprint 0.12kg CO₂e." With this value, the customer can tell end consumers how much carbon the package emits. The compliance basis for product-level carbon labels is ISO 14067:2018 "Product Carbon Footprint," which requires 3 things: ① product life cycle assessment (LCA), ② carbon emission data collection for each process, ③ third-party verification & certification.
Product-level carbon label costs (small & mid-sized printer, first year): ① ISO 14067 training + system establishment: 30,000–50,000 RMB; ② product life cycle assessment (LCA): 50,000–80,000 RMB; ③ third-party verification & certification: 50,000–100,000 RMB; ④ carbon label printing + database maintenance: 20,000–70,000 RMB/year. Total first-year cost 150,000–300,000 RMB, with subsequent annual maintenance of 50,000–100,000 RMB.
Product-level carbon label applicable scenarios: ① export to the EU of high-carbon products (EU CBAM Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism officially implemented in 2026); ② export to California, USA of high-carbon products (California carbon labeling act implemented in 2025); ③ customer-initiated requirements (e.g., supplier requirements from major brands like L'Oréal, Estée Lauder, Coca-Cola).
In practice, the Zhejiang printer only did product-level carbon labels after receiving the order from the L'Oréal subsidiary claim — but took it too late, as the order had already been placed before the printer started. As a result, costs could not be amortized. It is recommended that when the customer first asks about "carbon labels," printers first ask 3 questions: ① which brand is the customer (to determine whether product-level is needed), ② expected order amount (to determine whether the cost can be covered), ③ the cycle given by the customer (to determine whether delivery can be made on time). After clarifying these 3 questions, then decide whether to do product-level.
Type 2: Enterprise-Level Carbon Label — The "Disclosure Report" of the Printer's Overall Annual Carbon Emissions
Enterprise-level carbon label is the "disclosure report" of the printer's overall annual carbon emissions, such as "2024 carbon emissions 1200 tons CO₂e" or "Scope 1 direct emissions 800 tons / Scope 2 indirect emissions 400 tons." The compliance basis for enterprise-level carbon labels is ISO 14064-1:2018 "Organizational Greenhouse Gas Emissions," which requires 3 things: ① annual corporate carbon emission inventory, ② Scope 1 / 2 / 3 data collection, ③ third-party verification & certification.
Enterprise-level carbon label costs (small & mid-sized printer, first year): ① ISO 14064 training + system establishment: 20,000–30,000 RMB; ② annual corporate carbon emission inventory: 30,000–50,000 RMB; ③ third-party verification & certification: 20,000–50,000 RMB; ④ report disclosure + database maintenance: 10,000–20,000 RMB/year. Total first-year cost 80,000–150,000 RMB, with subsequent annual maintenance of 30,000–50,000 RMB.
Enterprise-level carbon label applicable scenarios: ① listed company supply chain requirements (HKEX, A-share ESG disclosure requirements); ② major customer (e.g., Apple, Huawei, Alibaba) supplier requirements; ③ printers exporting to the EU (CBAM requires Scope 1 + 2 data).
It is recommended that when the customer first asks about "carbon emission data," printers first do enterprise-level carbon labels — moderate cost, broad compliance coverage, able to meet most major customer requirements. Small & mid-sized printers with annual orders over 50 million RMB should complete the first enterprise-level carbon label before 2026 — this is a "low-cost, high-compliance" option.
Type 3: Process-Level Carbon Label — The "Database" of Carbon Emissions for a Single Process
Process-level carbon label is the carbon emission database for a single process, such as "offset printing CO₂e 50g/unit," "lamination CO₂e 30g/unit," "hot stamping CO₂e 80g/unit." The compliance basis for process-level carbon labels is ISO 14067 appendix + China Environmental Labelling (GB/T 24021), which requires 2 things: ① process carbon emission database collection, ② database query + label printing.
Process-level carbon label costs (small & mid-sized printer, first year): ① process carbon emission database collection: 10,000–20,000 RMB; ② database query system establishment: 5,000–10,000 RMB; ③ carbon label printing: 5,000–20,000 RMB/year. Total first-year cost 20,000–50,000 RMB, with subsequent annual maintenance of 10,000–20,000 RMB.
Process-level carbon label applicable scenarios: ① printer internal carbon management (carbon emission accounting for each order); ② "process carbon emission details" provided by the printer to the customer (used when the customer does product-level carbon footprint); ③ printer internal cost accounting (carbon cost included in order unit price).
It is recommended that printers do process-level carbon labels before enterprise-level carbon labels — lowest cost (first year 20,000–50,000 RMB), and provides basic data for enterprise-level and product-level. This choice is the most cost-effective for small & mid-sized printers — most printers do not need to do full product-level; doing process-level + enterprise-level first is enough to meet 90% of customer requirements.
Type 4: The "Compliance Boundaries" of the 3 Carbon Label Forms — What Scenarios Are Mandatory
The compliance boundaries of the 3 carbon label forms, by customer scenario:
①EU CBAM export scenario: must do enterprise-level + product-level. CBAM requires the printer to provide Scope 1 + 2 data (enterprise-level) + product carbon footprint (product-level). If either is missing, goods will be subject to additional carbon tariffs at EU customs.
②Major customer supply chain scenario (e.g., L'Oréal, Huawei, Apple): must do enterprise-level + process-level. These customers require the printer to provide annual carbon emission reports (enterprise-level) + carbon emission details for each process (process-level), used by the customer to do product-level carbon footprint.
③Regular customer scenario (small & mid-sized customers, domestic sales): can do only process-level. Regular customers have no hard requirement for carbon labels; printers only need to do a process-level carbon emission database, mainly used for internal cost accounting and "green marketing" selling points.
④ESG disclosure scenario (listed companies, exporters): must do enterprise-level. Listed companies and exporters must provide enterprise-level carbon emission data in accordance with ESG disclosure requirements.
In practice, when a customer asks about "carbon labels," printers should determine which type to do based on these 4 scenarios — to avoid either "doing everything and costs being too high" or "missing one item and being rejected by the customer."
Type 5: Small & Mid-Sized Printer "Carbon Label Priority" — 3-Step Implementation Path
The "carbon label implementation path" for small & mid-sized printers, in the order of "low cost → high cost," is divided into 3 steps:
Step 1: Process-level carbon label (first year 20,000–50,000 RMB). Purpose: establish the printer's internal carbon emission database, laying the foundation for subsequent enterprise-level and product-level. Applicable scenarios: printer internal carbon management + providing process carbon emission details to customers.
Step 2: Enterprise-level carbon label (first year 80,000–150,000 RMB). Purpose: meet listed company and major customer supply chain requirements. Applicable scenarios: HKEX / A-share ESG disclosure, major customer (L'Oréal / Huawei / Apple) supplier requirements, EU CBAM Scope 1 + 2 data.
Step 3: Product-level carbon label (first year 150,000–300,000 RMB). Purpose: carbon footprint value printed on each package. Applicable scenarios: export to the EU of high-carbon products, export to California, USA of high-carbon products, customer-initiated requirement for product-level carbon labels.
It is recommended that small & mid-sized printers proceed in the 3-step order — Step 1 process-level (lowest cost) → Step 2 enterprise-level (medium cost) → Step 3 product-level (highest cost). Leave 1–2 years between each step to avoid "all at once" cost pressure being too great.
In practice, a printer in Zhejiang first did process-level in 2024 (23,000 RMB), then enterprise-level in 2025 (102,000 RMB), and plans to do product-level in 2026 (based on customer needs) — this path is the optimal solution for "controllable cost, broad compliance coverage."
Further Reading
FAQ
What are the differences among the 3 forms of packaging printing carbon labels?
Product-level (the "CO₂e value" printed on each package), enterprise-level (the printer's overall annual carbon emission "disclosure report"), and process-level (the carbon emission "database" for a single process). The compliance bases for the 3 forms are ISO 14067 / ISO 14064 / GB/T 24021 respectively, and the costs are 150,000–300,000 / 80,000–150,000 / 20,000–50,000 RMB (first year).
Which type of carbon label should small & mid-sized printers do first?
First do process-level (first year 20,000–50,000 RMB), then enterprise-level in the second year (first year 80,000–150,000 RMB), then product-level in the third year (first year 150,000–300,000 RMB). This path has controllable cost and broad compliance coverage. Small & mid-sized printers do not need to do everything at once; first do process-level to establish basic data, then enterprise-level to meet major customers, and finally product-level for export.
What type of carbon label does EU CBAM require printers to do?
CBAM requires the printer to provide Scope 1 + 2 data (enterprise-level) + product carbon footprint (product-level). If either is missing, goods will be subject to additional carbon tariffs at EU customs. CBAM is officially implemented in 2026, covering 6 categories: steel, aluminum, fertilizer, cement, electricity, and hydrogen — currently packaging is not in the CBAM scope, but packaging for products in the CBAM scope will be affected.
How much does it cost for a printer to do product-level carbon labels?
Product-level carbon label first-year cost is 150,000–300,000 RMB, including: ① ISO 14067 training + system establishment 30,000–50,000 RMB; ② product life cycle assessment (LCA) 50,000–80,000 RMB; ③ third-party verification & certification 50,000–100,000 RMB; ④ carbon label printing + database maintenance 20,000–70,000 RMB/year. Subsequent annual maintenance cost is 50,000–100,000 RMB. It is recommended that printers calculate the cost clearly before receiving a customer order — be cautious about taking orders when the order amount cannot cover 80% of the cost.
How should the printer respond when the customer asks about "carbon labels"?
The printer should ask the customer 3 questions: ① which brand is the customer (to determine whether product-level is needed); ② expected order amount (to determine whether the cost can be covered); ③ the cycle given by the customer (to determine whether delivery can be made on time). After clarifying these 3 questions, decide which type of carbon label to do. Small & mid-sized printers doing process-level and enterprise-level first is enough to meet 90% of customer requirements; product-level should only be done when the customer explicitly requests it.
📚 📚 Related Recommendations
Need a Custom Packaging Solution?
Learn more about packaging, or consult directly for a custom solution and quote