Packaging Certification

What Do the CMA and CNAS Logos on a Test Report Actually Mean: 3 Real Boundaries—Where to Look First When Procuring a Report

📅 2026-11-18 ✍️ Wuxi Lexiang Printing & Packaging ⏱ 3min read

💡 💡 At a Glance

CMA certification applies to the qualifications of an institution, while CNAS accreditation applies to the capabilities of a laboratory; the two cannot replace one another. The third boundary is representativeness—the report applies only to the submitted sample, not to the production batch. Verification order: first check whether the mark and the institution fall within the scope of accreditation, then whether the capability annex covers the test item, and finally match the sample batch number with the actual production batch.

Last month, a client who makes mooncakes sent me a scanned copy of a third-party test report and asked me, “Is this the CMA report you mentioned?”

I enlarged the document to 300% and turned to the last page. The report had two stamps on it: one was a special stamp for inspection and testing, with the CMA mark in the bottom-right corner; the other bore the CNAS mark, with English wording on the stamp. The client added, “The other lab said they can test absolutely anything.”

I couldn’t reach a judgment based on these two marks alone. When it comes to test reports, the pitfalls lie almost entirely outside the marks. The marks only tell you “the identity of the institution that issued the report”; the actual limits of their validity lie in three other areas. If procurement and quality control personnel check only the marks, three out of ten reports will cause unnecessary alarm, while two actually indicate problems.

The first boundary: CMA and CNAS recognize different things

The most common misconception is treating CMA and CNAS as “the premium version and the lower-spec version,” assuming that CNAS necessarily makes an institution stronger than CMA.

In reality, the two accredit different entities.CMA is the qualification accreditation of inspection and testing institutions.Its accreditation target is the institution itself: whether the testing activities comply with regulations, whether the laboratory has adequate equipment, and whether its personnel are properly qualified are determined through the accreditation of the market regulation authority and are subject to administrative compulsion. Meanwhile,CNAS stands for laboratory accreditation.It assesses a laboratory’s technical competence: whether your methods, personnel, and participation in proficiency testing can meet the standards for international mutual recognition, as evaluated by a national accreditation body.

Therefore, the same organization may hold both CMA and CNAS, or only one of them; the scope of application of the two also differs. CMA primarily supports the issuance of reports for legally regulated domestic purposes, whereas CNAS supports international mutual recognition—that is, whether the report will be accepted by overseas clients.

The mooncake client obtained both documents, but that is not what he should really be concerned about. What he needs to know is whether the packaging can enter supermarkets and be used for import and export. Neither mark directly answers that.

The second boundary: the scope of accreditation is more valuable than the report itself.

This is the layer most likely to be overlooked and also the one most likely to cause problems.

When an organization obtains CMA or CNAS, it is not being issued an unrestricted license. The accredited competencies are listed separately—what tests it can perform, which standards it follows, and which parameters it covers. Each item is included in the schedule of accredited competencies.If the stamp on the report falls outside the scope of accreditation, that particular data item has no legal validity.This is not "a discount" but "untested."

I asked the client: Is the migration amount stated in the report based on a testing method you designated yourselves, or did the laboratory use the client-specified method as requested? He said he did not know; the report did not state this clearly.

This is the most common situation in practice: The client designates a method (such as an older version of a standard or a company-specific method), the laboratory follows it, and then stamps the report with its own seal.Results obtained using a client-specified method cannot be considered a routine report within the scope of the institution's accreditation.Its validity must be assessed separately, and many procurement departments and brand owners exclude such results from their compliance manuals.

Therefore, when obtaining a report, the correct sequence is three steps: First, confirm that the institution has the relevant mark; second, confirm that the test item on the report falls within the scope of the institution's schedule of accredited capabilities; and third, confirm whether the test item was tested using an institution-accredited standard method or a client-specified method. The second step is most often skipped and is also where problems are most readily identified during review.

The third type of boundary: The report proves the sample, not the entire batch of goods.

The third type of boundary is unrelated to the mark, but it is the most damaging.

The test report is legally responsible only forthe samples submitted for testing.The samples submitted were a box pulled from the customer’s warehouse, samples taken directly from the production line, or samples retained by the printing plant—these three sources carry very different implications.

One client who makes food cans for children had a flawless report: migration levels and heavy metals all passed. But when I asked where the samples came from, he said, “We took them from the previous batch of finished products.”

The paper used for that batch of finished products had been printed three months earlier, the ink was from the previous run, the production line had changed crews, and the warehouse humidity had also been different.This report proves the status of the batch produced three months ago; it cannot prove anything about the batch the client is currently producing and preparing to deliver.The industry calls this “decoupling the report from the batch”—no matter how genuine the report itself is, it is meaningless when applied to the question of whether this particular batch is compliant.

Closing this loophole does not depend on urging the client to resubmit samples for testing. Instead, three things should be written into the order when it is placed: which batch the submitted samples should come from, who should take them (the printing plant’s retained sample / the client’s own collection / third-party witness), and how the returned report should be linked to the batch number of this particular shipment. Whether the batch number is printed on the packaging, and where it appears, is a separate issue, but it must first exist.

The report only counts if all three checks are passed.

Returning to the mooncake client, I ultimately gave him one piece of advice: don’t ask whether the report has CMA certification yet. Instead, ask three questions—whether food-contact materials are included in the laboratory’s scope of accreditation, whether migration testing used a laboratory-accredited method or the method specified by the client, and which batch the samples were taken from, including whether the lot numbers can be matched to the delivered batch.

If all three checks are passed, the report is usable before the product goes into inventory. If any one check fails, it is merely “an official-looking piece of paper.”

Incidentally, in many packaging orders, inspection reports serve two different purposes: one is for the client to submit to an e-commerce platform or retailer to demonstrate compliance, and the other is for the client to use in deciding whether to place the order. For the former, it is enough for the report to be formally compliant; for the latter, the testing methods and representativeness must be clarified.The same report cannot serve both purposes.As a result, many procurement teams habitually send just one report and move on, only for it to be rejected during the platform’s random inspection.

Further reading

There are several other articles on testing that are relevant:

#Packaging Certification #Test Report #CMA Mark #CNAS Accreditation #Laboratory #Food Contact Materials #Packaging Testing

FAQ

Does having the CMA mark mean the report is valid nationwide?

Does not equal. CMA is an accreditation of the institution’s qualifications. The mark only indicates that the institution is qualified to issue such reports, and is valid only within the scope of accredited testing capabilities, projects, and standard methods. If the testing falls outside the accredited scope, the method is not an institutionally recognized method, or the sample source does not correspond to the actual batch, the report may still be formally compliant but has no practical validity.

Can reports issued by a laboratory that has CNAS accreditation but not CMA accreditation be used?

It depends on the intended use. CNAS accreditation recognizes a laboratory’s technical competence and supports international mutual recognition, so it generally carries more weight when used for exports or overseas clients. However, in domestic statutory scenarios or when registering on a platform, many recipients explicitly require the institution to hold CMA certification. The two cannot replace each other. The safest approach is to confirm who the report is intended for before accepting the order.

Is there a problem if the customer specifies the testing method and the laboratory follows it and then affixes the CMA seal?

The method itself can be used, but the results cannot be considered a standard report within the scope of the laboratory's accreditation. The accreditation scope covers standard methods recognized by the laboratory; data obtained using customer-specified methods are often handled separately in terms of legal validity and the customer's compliance manual. The prudent approach is to also perform a set of tests using an accreditation-recognized method for comparison, or to clearly state the source of the method in the report.

The report applies only to the submitted sample. How will batch consistency be ensured?

Rely on three traceable fields: the lot number of the sample submitted for testing, the sampler, and the production records corresponding to the lot. The contract or purchase order should clearly specify which lot the sample was taken from, who took it, and how the returned report will be matched to the delivered lot. Whether to print the lot number on the packaging is a separate decision, but the production lot number must first exist in the printer’s sample retention records.

The platform’s spot check was rejected, even though a third-party compliance report had already been submitted. Why?

The common reason is that the report does not match its intended use. The report the customer submits to the platform may have been prepared using samples from the previous batch of finished products or retained samples from the printing plant, which are not from the same batch as the platform’s current inspection; alternatively, the sample quantity and sampling plan may not meet the platform’s requirements. The solution is to prepare separate reports: one for submission to the platform and another for use in placing orders, and ensure that the batch inspected by the platform can be matched to the order batch number.

The testing institution’s capability annex cannot be seen by the customer. How can this be verified?

You can require the institution to clearly list the standard methods and testing items it plans to use at the quotation stage and specify whether they fall within the scope of its accreditation; before formally commissioning it, request the institution’s publicly available accreditation certificate and information on how to verify its scope of accreditation. The testing institution can recommend this directly in its explanation to the client, which is less trouble than reviewing the report after the fact.

Need a Custom Packaging Solution?

Learn more about packaging, or consult directly for a custom solution and quote